The Cat as an Invasive Species - A beloved Pet with a heavy Econological Footprint
Published in the newspaper Amigoe on the 18th of November 2026
A bowl of water, some kibble and a cat that gratefully walks up. Anyone who feeds a stray cat wants to help an animal. Yet the same cat can grab a lizard or kill a bird chick a little later. Therein lies the dilemma: a beloved pet can also be a threat to wild animals. On Curaçao, where special species live together in a small area, this requires responsibility.
The domestic cat, Felis catus, has been spread by humans all over the world and is not part of the original fauna of Curaçao. Where introduced cats settle and harm native animals, they function as invasive alien species. That is an ecological description, not a moral judgment. The cat follows her hunting instinct. People decide where she ends up and how much space she gets to hunt.
Not only feral cats cause damage. Stray cats, and domestic cats that roam outside, also catch wild animals. A full feeder does not disable the hunting instinct. For a bird or lizard, it makes little difference whether the attacker has an owner. Tackling only the shy, hard-to-approach cats therefore leaves part of the problem in place.
Why islands are vulnerable
Many island animals developed without the hunting pressure of predatory mammals that were later introduced by humans. Their populations are often small and have few alternative options. Birds that breed on the ground are especially easily accessible. Moreover, a colony can continue to count adult birds for years, while hardly any young survive. The deterioration then only becomes visible late.
Nest of the laughing gull with 2 chicks on the ground (Credit: Donna A. Dewhurst / USFWS)
On Curaçao, ground birds such as the tapa kaminda, the sprinkhaangors and the sloke deserve special attention. This also applies to breeding colonies of terns, the kaweta di pata and the shon Piet. Small mammals such as the Curaçao field mouse and the Curaçao rabbit and reptiles such as the Curaçao snake can also fall prey to cats. The Wageningen report on invasive species from 2025 mentions cats as a possible explanation for the lack of certain small land mammals and ground birds on Bonaire that still occur on neighboring islands. That is a clue, not proof that cats are solely responsible for this.
How many wild animals cats kill annually on the main island of Curaçao cannot be reliably determined from the sources consulted. Foreign numbers should therefore not simply be converted to our situation. But the regional examples show that the risk to vulnerable breeding sites is concrete.
One cat can do a lot of damage
The report describes how on Saba a feral cat attacks an almost flightless young of the red-billed tropicbird from a nest. This seabird breeds in rock cavities and lays only one egg per breeding attempt. The loss of that one young therefore means that this breeding attempt does not produce an offspring.
A cat attacks a young of the red-billed tropicbird
For Bonaire, the same report mentions an event recorded by researcher P. Bertuol in which one stray cat destroyed a tern colony of more than thirty breeding pairs in one night. Such an example shows why even a few cats can be a serious problem in a breeding colony. The number of cats alone does not say enough about the possible damage.
Klein Curaçao shows recovery
Close to home, Klein Curaçao offers a hopeful example. In July 2001, researchers found an abandoned colony of American Little Terns, with dead terns scattered around the breeding site. This indicated possible cat predation. Carmabi removed the feral cats in October of that year. The goats had already been removed earlier. Between 2000 and 2005, native trees, shrubs, herbs and grasses were planted.
Research by Debrot and co-researchers, published in 2023, describes the subsequent recovery. In 2002, a maximum of 140 breeding pairs of one species had been documented: the American Little Tern. In 2021, more than 430 breeding pairs of seabirds and coastal birds were recorded together, in 2022 about 650. During the study in 2021 and 2022, the breeding of eight additional species was confirmed. The Sooty Tern and Bridled Tern even resulted in new breeding registrations for Curaçao.
The researchers described Klein Curaçao as the most species-rich and active seabird breeding site in the archipelago. The removal of harmful imported mammals made recovery possible. However, it is not possible to determine exactly how large the individual share of cat removal was: the disappearance of goats and the recovery of vegetation also changed the island.
Moreover, more breeding pairs do not automatically mean that enough young fledge. In followed nests of theCayenne tern, all eggs disappeared in 2021. Wildlife cameras recorded how rats took eggs, sometimes as early as the night after they were laid. Restoration therefore calls attention to both the return of breeding birds and their actual breeding success.
Cats are not reliable rat exterminators
A common argument is that cats are necessary to control rats. The Wageningen report warns against this assumption. On Saba, cats were mainly found in low, dry areas, while rats more often used the higher, densely vegetated parts. As a result, their habitats do not overlap sufficiently to be able to count on effective control.
Research elsewhere also shows that cats catch relatively few rats and can choose prey, such as birds and lizards, more easily. Less visible rats do not necessarily mean fewer rats: they can avoid cats. Klein Curaçao shows that bird recovery is possible after cat removal while rats remain present. At the same time, separate rat management is still necessary to protect eggs and chicks.
What can we do in Curaçao
The first step starts at home. Keep cats indoors or have a well-enclosed outdoor run with space to climb, hide, and play. Keeping wild animals indoors only at night does not sufficiently protect wild animals, because cats also hunt during the day. Neutering and sterilization prevent unwanted litters; Microchipping and registration help to bring back found animals. Those who can no longer take care of a cat must seek help with shelter or rehoming.
In TNR, or Trap, Neuter, Return, an important distinction is still needed. Sterilization prevents reproduction but does not stop hunting. Relocation to a vulnerable breeding colony does not remove the immediate danger. In residential areas, sterilization, adoption, and preventing abandonment can combine to limit growth. Around important breeding grounds, the goal should be to keep cats out sustainably. No new feeding spots or relocations fit there.
Captured animals require a careful and humane approach, with expert assessment and as much responsible shelter or relocation as possible. Feeding alone without follow-up management does not protect nature. Residents, hotels and restaurants can help by shielding food waste and working together with animal welfare organizations and nature managers.
Protecting requires perseverance
On Klein Curaçao, the researchers also warn of reintroduction of cats and disturbance by visitors. The study even mentions that from 2019 onwards, a well-groomed domestic cat was present again. An earlier removal therefore does not offer a permanent guarantee. Information, agreements with tour operators, protection of breeding zones and repeated checks remain necessary.
For Curaçao, a practical start is to make an inventory of cats around vulnerable breeding sites and to monitor nests: how many eggs hatch and how many young fledge? Government, veterinarians, volunteers and nature managers can coordinate joint measures accordingly. Klein Curaçao shows that recovery is possible. Care for cats should go hand in hand with care for the wild animals they hunt.
Foto in heading: Brisbane City Council (CC BY 2.0)